Witch Hat Brownies – 5 Spooky Tips for a Perfect Halloween Treat

Witch Hat Brownies are fun, festive, and packed with chocolatey goodness—perfect for your Halloween dessert table. Whether you’re baking for a costume party, spooky school event, or just enjoying fall baking at home, these cute cone-topped brownies will steal the spotlight. In this guide, I’ll show you how to make them from scratch and decorate them with flair.

The Story & Intro to Witch Hat Brownies

One October afternoon when I was ten, my mom surprised us with something straight out of a Halloween storybook—witch hat brownies. They were simple brownies topped with green frosting and upside-down chocolate cones to make little hats. We decorated them with sprinkles, candy belts, and edible glitter. That memory stuck with me, and now it’s a yearly tradition I share with my own kids.

These witch hat brownies start with a fudgy brownie base—made from butter, cocoa, and a few pantry staples. Once baked and cooled, each brownie becomes the base for a whimsical witch hat made from a frosted chocolate cone. It’s a hands-on decorating activity and dessert rolled into one.

The best part is how flexible they are. You can dye the frosting green, purple, or orange using natural colors like matcha or beet powder. Add Halloween-themed sprinkles or wrap licorice strings around the cone for a hatband effect. Want more spooky snack ideas? Check out Easy Halloween Food and Halloween Desserts for inspiration.

These witch hat brownies are a hit with kids and adults alike. They’re not just cute—they’re chewy, chocolatey, and packed with personality. And if you need a spooky sidekick treat, our Monster Cupcakes are always a crowd-pleaser.

Halloween just isn’t complete without a batch of witch hat brownies on the table.

Decorating & Frosting Ideas for Witch Hat Brownies

Creative Frosting Options for Witch Hat Brownies

When it comes to decorating witch hat brownies, the magic is in the frosting. It’s what holds the cone in place and brings the whole spooky hat to life. While classic buttercream is a go-to for many, you can get creative depending on your theme, taste, or dietary needs.

For a vibrant, witchy look, use a basic frosting base—powdered sugar mixed with milk or plant-based alternatives like almond or soy. Add green food coloring for the classic witch look, or go bold with purple, black, or even neon orange. Natural alternatives work great here too—matcha gives a ghoulish green, while activated charcoal or beet powder adds dramatic tones without artificial dyes.

Want a richer topping? Whip up a small batch of Chocolate Cupcakes. The glossy finish creates a sleek, magical vibe that makes your cones look like they came straight from a spellbook. Just let the ganache cool slightly before piping or spooning onto the brownies.

Not confident with piping bags? No worries. A simple zip-top bag with the corner cut off will give you just enough control. Use a swirling motion to create the “base” of the hat on each brownie square before placing the cone on top.

Spooky Halloween Brownie Decorations That Wow

Once you’ve frosted your brownies and secured the cone “hats,” it’s time for the fun part: decorating! This is where kids (and grown-ups) love to get involved.

Here are a few spooky decoration ideas:

• Wrap thin licorice around the base of the cone to look like a hatband.
• Use colored sugar or edible glitter for a shimmer effect.
• Add Halloween-themed sprinkles—bats, pumpkins, or candy eyes.

Want to elevate the cones themselves? Dip them in melted chocolate and let them harden before assembling. It adds a polished finish and helps keep them crisp overnight. For even more easy decoration ideas, check out our Halloween Mummy Cupcakes roundup.

For parties, place each brownie in a cupcake liner and arrange on a tray. They’re easy to grab and stay neat on display. These Halloween brownie decorations will have everyone reaching for seconds—and asking for the recipe.

Make-Ahead Tips & Party Presentation Ideas for Witch Hat Brownies

Make-Ahead Tips for Party-Perfect Witch Hat Brownies

One of the best things about witch hat brownies is how easy they are to prepare in advance. Halloween can get hectic—between decorating the house, finding costumes, and managing little goblins hopped up on candy, having your desserts ready to go is a huge relief.

Start by baking your brownies the day before. Once cooled, store them in an airtight container at room temperature. This keeps them moist and chewy without drying out. You can even freeze the uncut brownie slab for up to a week—just let it thaw overnight in the fridge before decorating.

As for the frosting, prepare it the night before and store it in the refrigerator. When you’re ready to assemble, bring it to room temperature and stir to restore its creamy texture. Color it fresh, or prep different colors in advance if you want variety.

The chocolate cones can also be pre-dipped in melted chocolate and hardened ahead of time. This not only adds a glossy finish but helps them keep their crisp texture when stored in a dry container. Wait to assemble everything until a few hours before your event to ensure the cones stay firm and upright.

How to Present Witch Hat Brownies at Your Halloween Bash

Presentation takes your Halloween desserts from fun to unforgettable. You don’t need fancy platters or cake stands—just a few creative tricks to make your brownies stand out.

Try placing each decorated brownie in a Halloween-themed cupcake liner or mini cauldron-shaped paper cup. Arrange them on a black tray scattered with candy corn or spider webbing. If you’re hosting kids, label each with fun names like “Witch Wands” or “Bewitched Bites” for added charm.

You can even build individual take-home dessert boxes with a witch hat brownie, napkin, and mini glow stick. It’s a party favor and dessert in one—and guests will remember it long after the party ends.

Creative, fun, and totally make-ahead friendly, witch hat brownies deserve the spotlight at your Halloween bash.

Ariations, Vegan Options & Final Tips for Witch Hat Brownies

Fun Variations on Witch Hat Brownies for Every Guest

One reason I love baking witch hat brownies is how easily they adapt to different tastes and dietary needs. Whether you’re serving a crowd with allergies or just want to mix things up, there are simple ways to make these treats work for everyone.

Going gluten-free? Swap the all-purpose flour for a gluten-free blend—just be sure it includes xanthan gum to keep the texture chewy. For a dairy-free or vegan version, use plant-based butter and flax eggs (1 tablespoon ground flaxseed + 3 tablespoons water per egg). Almond or oat milk works great for the frosting too.

Looking to upgrade the flavor? Add a layer of chocolate ganache on top of the brownies before frosting. It adds a rich, luxurious finish and helps hold the cone hats in place. You can find a simple version in our Chocolate Recipe guide, which works with both dairy and non-dairy cream.

Want to add crunch? Stir in mini pretzels or chopped walnuts to the brownie batter. For a spooky twist, use crushed Oreos or chocolate sandwich cookies as “dirt” on top of the frosting base. You’ll find more of these twists in our Easy Halloween Food collection that’s packed with crowd-pleasers.

These playful tweaks mean you can serve witch hat brownies that fit your crowd without sacrificing taste or fun.

Last-Minute Tips for Foolproof Witch Hat Brownies

Here are a few quick tips I’ve learned after making these for years:

• Cool completely before decorating or the frosting will melt.
• Level your brownie cuts with a warm knife for clean edges.
• Use firm cones—cheaper brands sometimes crumble, so test one first.
• Want sharp photos for social media? Chill the finished brownies for 10 minutes before taking pics to firm everything up.

Above all, have fun. This recipe isn’t about perfection—it’s about creativity and celebration. Whether you make them spooky, silly, or glam, witch hat brownies bring the Halloween spirit to life.

FAQ About Witch Hat Brownies & Halloween Dessert Tips

Conclusion: Why Witch Hat Brownies Are the Star of Halloween

From their spooky appearance to their irresistible chocolatey base, witch hat brownies are the ultimate Halloween dessert. They’re fun to bake, even more fun to decorate, and endlessly customizable to fit your theme or guest list. Whether you’re hosting a full-blown bash or just enjoying cozy treats at home, these brownies bring the festive spirit to life.

They’re easy to prep, work for various diets, and double as a fun activity for kids. With endless decoration ideas—from ganache drizzles to candy buckles—you’ll never make them the same way twice.

So, preheat that oven, pull out your favorite sprinkles, and let’s make some memories—one witchy brownie at a time.

Need more recipes? Follow me on Pinterest.

Print